Cognition, Brain, & Behavior Research Seminar
(Psychology 3340. Research Seminar in Cognition, Brain, and Behavior)


Spring 2007
2/01/07 Robert Stickgold (Harvard Medical School - Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center)
Sleep, Memory, and Dreams: A Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective [More...]
2/08/07 Massimo Piatelli-Palmerini (University of Arizona/Visiting)
Rethinking language, evolution and the evolution of language [More...]
2/15/07 Jason Mitchell (Harvard Psychology)
Inferring the mental states of similar and dissimilar others [More...]
2/22/07 Kyle Cave (UMass Amherst)
When Top-Down Attentional Control Turns Off [More...]
3/1/07 Justin Wood (Harvard Psychology)
Remembering actions and events in visual working memory [More...]
3/08/07 Angela Gutchess (Harvard Psychology)
Memory Specificity with Age [More...]
3/15/07 David Somers (Boston University)
Visual, Tactile and Spatial Attentional Processing in Human Occipital and Parietal Cortex [More...]
3/22/07 Samuel Moulton (Harvard Psychology)
The psychological effects of meditation [More...]
3/29/07 Spring Break
4/05/07 Jacob Beck (Harvard Philosophy)
The language of thought reconsidered [More...]
4/12/07 Ramakrishna Chakravarthi (Harvard Psychology)
Mechanisms in Visual Crowding [More...]
4/19/07 Ryan Bogdan (Harvard Psychology)
The Contributions of Stress and Genetics to Reward Processing: Implications for Depression [More...]
4/26/07 Joshua Greene (Harvard Psychology)
What Pushes Your Moral Buttons? [More...]
5/03/07 Sheila Blumstein (Brown University)
Phonetic Category Structure and the Mapping of Sound Structure to the Lexicon: Evidence from Lesion Studies and Functional Neuroimaging [More...]
Robert Stickgold
Sleep, Memory, and Dreams: A Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective


The concept of "sleeping on a problem" is familiar to most of us. But with myriad stages of sleep, forms of memory and processes of memory encoding and consolidation, sorting out how sleep contributes to memory has been anything but straightforward. Nevertheless, converging evidence, from the molecular to the phenomenological, leaves little doubt that offline memory reprocessing during sleep is an important component of how our memories are formed and ultimately shaped.
Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini
Rethinking language, evolution and the evolution of language


In this talk, I will present a re-conceptualization of several core issues in the biology and evolution of language. An appropriate sub-title could, then, be (paraphrasing a classic 1961 paper by Warren Sturgis McCulloch): What is language, that it may have evolved, and what is biological evolution, that it may apply to language? New promising avenues of inquiry (in mainstream biology, but decidedly still a minority view in language evolution) have emerged towards new biological foundations of language. I think one has many reasons to be dissatisfied with the attempts to explain language evolution in terms of gradualist neo-Darwinian adaptations. Such dissatisfaction is justified by the frequent neglect, or the denial, of central properties of language (unlimited recursion, computational compactness at the expense of communicability, parametrization, strict compositionality, headedness, endocentricty, conservativity etc.). The Evo-Devo approach now offers a powerful unifying perspective with a common plan in all the "bilateral" body forms, along over 550 million years, with what we are entitled to see as minor "parametric" genetic variations. Some lessons from the "new biology" towards rethinking the evolution of language will be suggested.
Jason Mitchell
Inferring the mental states of similar and dissimilar others


Unlike most other things in the world, human beings are driven by their internal mental states - what they think, feel, and desire. Accordingly, successful social interaction requires that we be capable of inferring the content of another person's mind, an ability known as "mentalizing." But by what cognitive processes does one go about inferring others' mental states? One possibility is that perceivers may sometimes be able to "simulate" another person's mental states by imagining themselves in the same situation and assuming that others would share the same thoughts and feelings that they experience themselves. However, this simulationist strategy would only be appropriate if one is willing to assume that the other person is sufficiently similar to self that he or she would indeed experience the same mental states as oneself. A recent series of neuroimaging and behavioral experiments has provided initial evidence in support of this prediction of simulation theory. First, we have observed that a brain region previously linked to self-referential thought (ventromedial prefrontal cortex) activates selectively for mentalizing about similar others. Second, we have demonstrated that perceivers more rapidly judge their own mental states after making the same judgment about a similar (relative to dissimilar) other. Finally, our most recent work has shown "repetition suppression" in the functional activation during self-reference following judgments of a similar other, suggesting that the same processing accompanies judgments of self and similar others.
Kyle Cave
When Top-Down Attentional Control Turns Off


When a visual object that is attended is partially occluded by a distractor object, the occluded region is inhibited, but only under certain conditions. This distractor region is apparently inhibited only when the display is fairly simple. If the configuration of objects is too complex, it may be too difficult to determine which regions belong to which objects. In a different set of experments, subjects search for a single target or for two targets simultaneously. The two targets have different colors. In single-target search, color is used effectively to prevent fixations of nontargets. During dual-target search, however, distractors with nontarget colors are fixated more often, indicating a partial break-down in top-down attentional control. These two findings demonstrate very different aspects of attention, but both show how top-down attentional control can be overwhelmed by complexity in the stimulus or in the task. Together they help to define the limits of top-down attentional control.
Justin Wood
Remembering actions and events in visual working memory


Humans depend on the ability to remember the actions of other individuals, information which needs to be stored in a temporary buffer to guide behavior after actions have been observed. To date, however, the storage capacity, contents, and architecture of visual working memory (VWM) for observed actions are unknown. In this talk, I present a series of studies which characterize the storage capacity and contents of VWM for actions and other types of events. Further, I investigate the architecture of VWM more generally, by asking how memory for actions and events interacts with other VWM systems, such as those used to store information about objects and spatial locations.
Angela Gutchess
Memory Specificity with Age


Young adults exhibit highly specific neural responses to certain types of information, such as object categories or social stimuli. This specificity is also present in the domain of memory, distinguishing between encoding processes or to the relatedness of information at the time of retrieval. In contrast, aging is marked by more generalized responses. For example, there is a less distinct neural response to classes of objects with age, and older adults activate both hemispheres for tasks on which young activate only one. To date, there has been little research addressing the degree to which specificity in memory is preserved with age. I will present three lines of work that address this question across stimulus features (background contexts vs. objects), modalities (self vs. other), and encoding processes (perceived vs. self-generated images). Although elderly adults show some preservation of distinct responses, age-related changes occur in the processes engaged during encoding and recognition. These changes may explain the pervasiveness of memory impairments with age in that, compared to young, older adults fail to engage cognitive control processes and access less specific information about the memory trace during retrieval.
David Somers
Visual, Tactile and Spatial Attentional Processing in Human Occipital and Parietal Cortex


fMRI has proven a very useful tool for localizing the neural substrates of human cognition and perception; however, the spatial resolution is limited by inter-subject averaging methods. We have employed within-subject methods to gain a clearer picture. We are now able to observe 14 distinct visual hemifield maps in human cerebral cortex. This includes five areas, V7, IPS1, IPS2, IPS3 and IPS4 that tile the medial bank of the intraparietal sulcus (IPS), an area of the brain known to support visual attention, visual STM, and multisensory interactions. These visual maps are consistent within individuals, but there are important differences across individuals. Although group-analysis of tactile and visual activation patterns suggests a region of overlapping multisensory activation in IPS, our within-subject analysis reveals that visual and tactile activations in IPS fit together like interlocking puzzle pieces within minimal overlap. Surprisingly, we find evidence for a degree of multimodal integration in primary visual cortex, as V1 is activated during tactile perception in blindfolded subjects. We have also investigated the mechanisms which support visual attention to more than one object location. We find that the attentional spotlight can be split to attend to multiple objects and that this divided spotlight modulates all visual cortical areas. The spotlight can be split within and across hemifields. Splitting the attentional spotlight can be an efficient strategy as it conserves attentional resources, withholding attention from irrelevant regions of the visual field. This Resource Conservation benefit is observed in Occipital Lobe BOLD signal. However, splitting the spotlight places a burden on attentional control circuitry in parietal and frontal lobes. BOLD signal activation in occipital and parietal cortex predicts overall behavioral performance via a two-stage model. Finally, our results conflict with the notion of independent hemispheric processing in visual attention: occipital hemispheres compete for attentional resources and IPS hemispheres cooperate.
Samuel Moulton
The psychological effects of meditation


Although recent reviews of meditation research have focused on its physiological, psychophysiological, or therapeutic effects, the claim that meditation improves cognitive functioning has not been systematically examined. I will present preliminary results from a meta-analysis of the relationship between meditative experience and cognitive abilities in an attempt to answer the question: does meditation make you smarter? I will also present results from several original studies assessing the relationship between meditative practice and emotional processing.
Jacob Beck
The language of thought reconsidered


According to the Language of Thought Hypothesis, cognition is dominated by representations that are structurally analogous to the sentences of a language. In my presentation, I will argue against this Hypothesis on both philosophical and empirical grounds. I will raise objections to three prominent arguments that philosophers and cognitive scientists have advanced in favor of the Language of Thought Hypothesis, and marshal empirical evidence that cognitive representations come in a variety of formats, many of which do not resemble sentences. The resulting view is that cognition is subserved by a plurality of representational kinds.
Ramakrishna Chakravarthi
Mechanisms in Visual Crowding


When a target is surrounded by distracters, it can no longer be easily identified. This phenomenon - known as Visual Crowding - is quite common in our visual experience. An understanding of crowding might shed light on several essential visual processes such as attention, search, reading, and awareness, among others. In a series of three studies I explore the mechanisms that underlie this phenomenon. Study 1, which looks at the temporal properties of a specific aspect of crowding, shows that crowding is not a low-level interaction but has features of attention. Study 2 demonstrates that crowding exhibits a signature of selective attention. Finally, Study 3 indicates that signal integrity of the distracters, but not their representation, is crucial for crowding to occur. That is, crowding seems to be a mid level interaction between the target and the distracters. In conclusion, current evidence strongly supports, although it does not confirm, an attentional hypothesis of crowding: crowding is due to a limitation in the resolution of attention. According to this hypothesis, attention cannot zoom in beyond a lower bound and if several objects happen to fall within this limit, their individual identities cannot be resolved crowding.
Ryan Bogdan
The Contributions of Stress and Genetics to Reward Processing: Implications for Depression


The heterogeneity of depression has hindered progress in identifying and understanding the genetic and environmental factors that contribute to this debilitating disorder. To reduce this heterogeneity and improve our etiological understanding it has been suggested that researchers target specific phenotypes of depression rather than investigate the overall disorder. Anhedonia, the loss of pleasure or lack of reactivity to pleasurable stimuli, is a promising phenotype to investigate as it is hypothesized to be a trait marker for depression and has been associated with dysfunction in the brain's reward system in preclinical models. Three studies will be presented that investigate how hedonic capacity is affected by 1) stress, 2) broad genetics and 3) the interaction of serotonin transporter genotype and stress.
Joshua Greene
What Pushes Your Moral Buttons?


In recent years, many hypothetical people have been killed by hypothetical runaway trolleys. This is not necessarily a bad thing, since the sacrifice of these victims was, in each case, offset by the saving of five other people's lives. In some cases people judge these trade-offs to be morally acceptable, while in other cases they don't. Why? A dual-process theory of moral judgment (supported by fMRI, neuropsychological, and behavioral data) offers a partial answer: People say "No" when they have an alarm-like emotional response that inclines them to disapprove of the action in question. In the absence of such responses, people tend toward a more "cognitive," utilitarian (cost-benefit) mode of moral judgment that inclines them to say "Yes." This is a partial answer because it doesn't explain why people respond more emotionally to some cases rather than others. I will discuss a series of behavioral experiments involving a number of "trolley variations" aimed at (a) isolating the features of harmful actions that trigger the aforementioned emotional responses and (b) understanding the cognitive mechanisms that govern these responses.
Sheila Blumstein
Phonetic Category Structure and the Mapping of Sound Structure to the Lexicon: Evidence from Lesion Studies and Functional Neuroimaging


This research investigates how the functional architecture of the speech-lexical processing system maps on to the neural systems underlying it. To this end, we will first examine the nature of phonetic category structure and the influence of top-down lexical information on phonetic processing (the lexical effect).

Evidence from studies of aphasia and functional neuroimaging suggests that
∗the phonetic processing stream is a distributed network that includes temporal, parietal, and frontal structures with details of phonetic category structure retained throughout the stream
∗modulation of activation in frontal areas emerges as a function of acoustic-phonetic competition, not phonetic quality, whereas modulation of activation in posterior areas appears to reflect ´goodness of fit´ to a phonetic category.
∗the influence of lexicality on phonetic category structure reflects both perceptual and decision-related, post-lexical processes

We will then explore the mapping of sound structure to lexical form and the lexical-semantic network by investigating the effects of phonological-lexical competition and lexical density on lexical access. Results suggest that:
∗both anterior (inferior frontal gyrus) and posterior (superior temporal gyrus) structures are influenced by phonological-lexical competition but in different ways
∗effects of phonological lexical density emerge in the supramarginal gyrus for both perception and production, suggesting that there is a common lexicon accessed for both perception and production and that this parietal area is recruited when increased processing demands are required for accessing phonological form